For decades, the American dream often meant moving to the suburbs, buying a house with a yard, and planting roots in a quieter community away from the bustle of city life. But that picture is quickly changing. According to Realtor.com’s May 2025 Rental Report, more suburban homes are being occupied by renters, not owners, as rising housing costs and high mortgage rates shut many buyers out of the market.
This shift isn’t just a short-term hiccup it’s a trend that could redefine what suburban living means in the years ahead. (Realtor.com Source)
Suburbs: Once for Buyers, Now for Renters
Traditionally, suburbs were the middle ground between affordability and comfort. Homeownership rates were higher outside city centers, and families moved there to escape rising urban rents. But the tables are turning:
-
More Rentals Are Available: Developers are increasingly building rental homes and multi-family units in suburban neighborhoods, catering to the growing renter population.
-
Ownership Has Become Harder: Mortgage rates remain elevated, and home prices in many suburbs continue to climb. The gap between the cost of owning and renting is widening, and renters are stepping in where buyers can’t.
This means the suburbs, once a buyer’s market, are becoming a competitive landscape for renters seeking affordability and space.
The Numbers Behind the Trend
The May 2025 data paints a striking picture:
-
Median Rent (Top 50 Metros): $1,705 per month down 1.7% year-over-year.
-
Studios: Asking rents are 1.9% lower than last year.
-
One-Bedrooms: Down 2.3% year-over-year.
-
Two-Bedrooms: Down 1.7%.
While these declines offer some relief, they are modest compared to how much rents surged during the pandemic and in the years that followed. Today’s rents still sit well above 2019 pre-pandemic levels, though they remain under the record highs of late 2022.
This means that while affordability has improved slightly for renters, the dream of buying a suburban home continues to slip further away.
Why Suburbs Are Losing Their Ownership Edge
Several factors are fueling the shift from owning to renting in suburban areas:
-
High Mortgage Rates: Elevated borrowing costs have added hundreds of dollars to monthly payments, putting ownership out of reach for many.
-
Stubbornly High Home Prices: Even as rents ease, home prices in many suburban markets have not budged significantly, making down payments harder to save for.
-
Income vs. Housing Costs: Wages haven’t kept pace with the rapid rise in housing costs, squeezing middle-income families.
-
Lifestyle Preferences: A new generation of workers and families are valuing flexibility over ownership. Renting allows them to move for work, lifestyle changes, or simply to avoid being locked into a long-term mortgage.
-
Supply Shifts: Developers are catching on new construction increasingly leans toward rental communities rather than single-family homes for sale.
Regional Trends Worth Noting
-
Education Hubs (e.g., San Jose, Boston, Seattle): Areas that typically attract international students are seeing softer rental demand due to policy changes, impacting overall rental growth.
-
Government Employment Markets (e.g., Washington D.C., Baltimore): Rents are fluctuating as federal employment hubs experience varied economic pressures.
-
Sunbelt States: Many suburban communities in the South and West are seeing strong rental demand as population growth continues, fueled by migration from higher-cost states.
These regional differences highlight how localized the renting vs. buying equation has become.
What This Means for You
For Renters
The current market could work in your favor. With rental prices softening in many suburban areas, now is a good time to explore neighborhoods that may have been out of reach a few years ago. Tenants also have more leverage in negotiating lease terms, especially in areas with high rental supply.
For Aspiring Homeowners
It’s a tougher road ahead. Buyers need to carefully weigh whether it makes sense to wait for mortgage rates to drop, expand their search radius, or consider smaller homes. Financial planning including aggressive saving strategies will be key.
For Policymakers & Developers
This shift signals a pressing need to address supply imbalances. Expanding zoning for affordable housing, incentivizing construction of starter homes, and offering buyer assistance programs will be crucial in keeping the American dream alive for younger generations.
Looking Ahead: A Renter’s Suburb?
The American dream is evolving. While owning a suburban home is still possible for some, many households are redefining success as finding a stable, affordable rental in a community that offers good schools, green space, and access to jobs.
Suburbs may no longer be synonymous with homeownership, but they are becoming central to the story of modern renting. This transformation raises bigger questions about generational wealth, mobility, and the future of housing policy in the United States.
For now, one thing is clear: suburban living is still desirable but for many Americans, renting has become the only realistic path to enjoying it.
Source: Realtor.com – Americans Priced Out of Buying Homes in the Suburbs (Rental Report, May 2025) Read the full article here